A Side Trip Throught Bankruptcy, Factoring and Legal Malpractice

Gatto v Burke & Burke, NY Slip Op 32511, Nassau County, Justice Bucaria illustrates a two part transactional represent ion by attorneys of the clients in a business sale case. Facts are simple: plaintiff sells restaurant to X and uses target attorneys as transactional counsel. Sale documents do not have a security interest for Plaintiff-seller. End of phase one.

Sale goes sour, and buyer files bankruptcy. Seller again retains target attorney to represent them in suit against buyer and then in bankruptcy court. Seller has no security interest and is treated as an ordinary creditor, losing the proceeds.

Question is whether statute of limitations begins to run on mistake date when transaction closes without a security interest, or it there is continuing representation, or whether there are two different and non-continuing retentions such that the s/l has already run on the mistake.

Here, the court found that it was continuing. Read the decision for the Justice's reasoning. It is based upon the interconnectedness of the sale and the remedy work by the attorneys.

We have commented about the Collateral Estoppel trap in legal malpractice with regard to fee arbitrations and hearings. in short, when a court grants an attorney fee application, it implicitly determines that there can have been no malpractice, as the court may not award fees in the face of malpractice. Fee arbitrations and hearings in state court happen, but not that often. Bankruptcy fee hearings happen in every case, and in every case where fees are awarded to counsel, the question of res judicata comes up.

In re D.A. ELIA CONSTRUCTION CORP., Plaintiff, v. DAMON & MOREY, LLP, Defendant.;07-CV-143A ; UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK; 389 B.R. 314; 2008 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 25496 has been the leading case on this issue. There, attorneys who had been granted fees were able to fend off legal malpractice claims based upon res judicata.

Now, in PENTHOUSE MEDIA GROUP, INC., , - against - PACHULSKI STANG ZIEHL & JONES LLP, ;UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK; 2009 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 46617 we see a slightly different result. Judge Scheindlin sitting in appeal of a US Bankruptcy decision by Judge Bernstein, finds that the legal malpractice plaintiffs did not have a full and fair opportunity to be heard, and that res judicata does not control the issue of legal malpractice.

"Although Pachulski's fee application was approved by the bankruptcy court in the prior proceeding, I cannot conclude as a matter of law that PMG had a full and fair opportunity to litigate allegations of Pachulski's malpractice during that hearing. Many of the factors used to consider whether a party had a full and fair opportunity to litigate an issue favor PMG, particularly given PMG's continued retention of Pachulski as its counsel. For instance, one of the factors courts have considered is "the importance of the claim in the prior litigation." 45 PMG had just undergone a reorganization with the help of Pachulski as its counsel. The possibility that Pachulski may have committed malpractice while representing PMG during that reorganization may not have been at the forefront of PMG's concerns. In addition, PMG [*16] had no "incentive [or] initiative to litigate" the malpractice issue, 46 considering that it expected Pachulski to continue to advise PMG in the winding down of its bankruptcy proceeding.

Of particular importance to this Court is the bankruptcy court's reliance on D.A. Elia Construction Corp. 50 Judge Bernstein concluded that D.A. Elia was directly on point, 51 but D.A. Elia is perhaps even more clearly distinguishable from the instant case than other cases cited by Pachulski, as in that case the malpractice claim was actually litigated during the fee application proceeding. D.A. Elia emphasized that
many of the same allegations made by Elia in its [malpractice] complaint were previously made by Elia in its objections to Damon & Morey's final fee application. Specifically, Elia argued to the bankruptcy court that the firm had labored under a conflict of interest, had committed legal malpractice and had failed to turn over money owed to the estate. The bankruptcy court provided Elia with ample opportunity [to] raise those claims, but ultimately rejected them as meritless. 52
The district court concluded that "it cannot be said that Elia was denied the opportunity to raise these [malpractice] claims in the prior action." 53 In the instant case, PMG raised no such objections [*19] at the fee hearing."


http://www.muangthai.com/edirectory/user_detail.php?u=ledoux
http://www.sportkatalogus.hu/user_detail.php?u=Armstrong
http://dccoverage.com/user_detail.php?u=rodriguez
http://www.joaillier-paris.com/user_detail.php?u=Davidson
http://www.realestatesagent.ca/user_detail.php?u=parks
http://www.livecasinomarket.com/user_detail.php?u=Leblanc
http://www.fto.ro/user_detail.php?u=Williams
http://www.onlinepharmacy-directory.com/user_detail.php?u=lynch
http://www.patiofurnitures.ca/user_detail.php?u=grosso
http://www.builderpatio.com/user_detail.php?u=henry
http://www.titlecompanylisting.com/user_detail.php?u=smoot
http://www.realestatesagents.ca/user_detail.php?u=whitchurch
http://www.dropshippingportal.com/user_detail.php?u=Simmons
http://www.autoadvance.ca/user_detail.php?u=claar
http://www.greatestbeachresorts.com/user_detail.php?u=Fontenot
http://www.fishings.ca/user_detail.php?u=andrews3232
http://intomartialarts.co.uk/user_detail.php?u=plowman
http://www.computer-part.ca/user_detail.php?u=seth
http://www.how-to-sell-your-business.com/user_detail.php?u=greene
http://www.careerscounseling.info/user_detail.php?u=holcombe
http://www.directoryleeds.com/user_detail.php?u=nickerson
http://www.wireless-warrior.org/user_detail.php?u=king
http://www.statesnorthdakota.com/user_detail.php?u=stoltzfus
http://dccoverage.com/user_detail.php?u=holland
http://www.how-to-sell-your-business.com/user_detail.php?u=fontenot
http://www.audiomastermind.com/user_detail.php?u=brown
http://www.careerscounseling.info/user_detail.php?u=moon
http://dogdirectory.citizencanine.org/user_detail.php?u=Whitchurch
http://www.fishings.ca/user_detail.php?u=garrett
http://www.cablestvs.com/user_detail.php?u=gomez
http://afamilyplace.com/user_detail.php?u=militello
http://www.how-to-sell-your-business.com/user_detail.php?u=sibley
http://www.audiomastermind.com/user_detail.php?u=thompson
http://www.sportkatalogus.hu/user_detail.php?u=Goode
http://www.armchair.ie/user_detail.php?u=Rodriguez
http://www.patiofurnitures.ca/user_detail.php?u=williams
http://www.realestatesagents.ca/user_detail.php?u=braun
http://www.slpwebsites.com/user_detail.php?u=williams
http://www.salonbeauty.ca/user_detail.php?u=goode
http://www.onlinepharmacy-directory.com/user_detail.php?u=cull
http://www.realestatesagent.ca/user_detail.php?u=adams
http://www.titlecompanylisting.com/user_detail.php?u=draper
http://www.fishlinkcentral.com/user_detail.php?u=Nickerson
http://gaysports.net.au/user_detail.php?u=willie
http://www.realestatesagent.ca/user_detail.php?u=davidson
http://www.sgblog.com/home/user_detail.php?u=Willie
http://www.podiatristphysician.com/user_detail.php?u=hall
http://www.statesnorthdakota.com/user_detail.php?u=hawkins
http://www.boatstraders.ca/user_detail.php?u=rodriguez
http://www.statesnorthdakota.com/user_detail.php?u=malone
http://www.intenox.com/user_detail.php?u=grosso
http://www.bcportcoquitlam.com/user_detail.php?u=Elmore
http://www.directory.am/user_detail.php?u=Acevedo
http://www.muangthai.com/edirectory/user_detail.php?u=dean
http://intomartialarts.co.uk/user_detail.php?u=belcher
http://www.realestatesagents.ca/user_detail.php?u=bumgarner
http://www.rodir.ro/user_detail.php?u=Crowe
http://www.directoryleeds.com/user_detail.php?u=matthews
http://www.audiomastermind.com/user_detail.php?u=miller
http://www.pizzascoupons.com/user_detail.php?u=waggoner
http://www.directoryleeds.com/user_detail.php?u=jenkins
http://www.builderpatio.com/user_detail.php?u=king87
http://www.muangthai.com/edirectory/user_detail.php?u=tenorio
http://intomartialarts.co.uk/user_detail.php?u=rodriguez
http://www.directory.am/user_detail.php?u=Minor
http://www.asturpyme.com/user_detail.php?u=hawkins
http://www.computer-part.ca/user_detail.php?u=jackson
http://www.livecasinomarket.com/user_detail.php?u=Waggoner
http://www.sdlil.com/user_detail.php?u=miller
http://www.builderpatio.com/user_detail.php?u=martin
http://www.rodir.ro/user_detail.php?u=Martin
http://dccoverage.com/user_detail.php?u=vann
http://www.titlecompanylisting.com/user_detail.php?u=jordan
http://gaysports.net.au/user_detail.php?u=cascio
http://www.intenox.com/user_detail.php?u=leblanc
http://wholesalesarong.com/fashion/user_detail.php?u=martin
http://www.builderhome.ca/user_detail.php?u=palermo
http://www.careerscounseling.info/user_detail.php?u=militello
http://www.cleanerlaunry.ca/user_detail.php?u=dean
http://www.patiofurnitures.ca/user_detail.php?u=puente
http://www.rodir.ro/user_detail.php?u=Gray
http://www.builderhome.ca/user_detail.php?u=hamilton
http://www.1stcyprus.com/user_detail.php?u=grider
http://www.intenox.com/user_detail.php?u=willie
http://www.antiquecollectiblestore.com/user_detail.php?u=andrews3232
http://www.onlinepharmacy-directory.com/user_detail.php?u=grider
http://links.vfxy.com/user_detail.php?u=hall
http://www.builderhome.ca/user_detail.php?u=simmons
http://www.fishings.ca/user_detail.php?u=peterson
http://www.directorymadisonwisconsin.com/user_detail.php?u=battles
http://links.vfxy.com/user_detail.php?u=holland
http://gaysports.net.au/user_detail.php?u=castillo
http://www.bcportcoquitlam.com/user_detail.php?u=Girard
http://www.kovai.org/user_detail.php?u=kinsey
http://www.directory.am/user_detail.php?u=Battles
http://www.sportkatalogus.hu/user_detail.php?u=Stuart
http://www.bcportcoquitlam.com/user_detail.php?u=Kinsey
http://www.computer-part.ca/user_detail.php?u=gomez
http://www.livecasinomarket.com/user_detail.php?u=Wirth
http://links.vfxy.com/user_detail.php?u=moon